Lorenzo's Pizzeria and Restaurant: Authentic Pizza Experience in Sussex

Pizza was well enjoyed by my family to my surprise. Glad to have finally found great pizza in the area.

This place might have the best Italian food I’ve ever had. The Italian salads were beautiful and scrumptious. My husband had mussels and eggplant rollatini and couldn’t stop raving. The sauce on the baked ziti was delicious. If you’re looking for great Italian food, this is the place.

Surprisingly, this little pizzeria tucked away in it's own little shop, was delicious. Pizza crust was excellent My son's chicken Parm with vodka sauce on a garlic not was delicious. My granddaughters chicken ranch with bacon wrap was excellent. Best to find hidden treasures when traveling

Quality food on a budget. I recommend their salads, what a great value. Best meat lovers pie in town. Fast in and out service!

We moved here about 10 years ago and we were kinda disappointed with pizza options/quality. It took us a while to find Lorenzos but thats when the obsession with their cheese fries started. Pizza is phenomenal. We switched to another local pizza joint only because they had online ordering for pick up, which is easier when ordering for our 7,009 kids who take 45 years to decide what they actually want. It's hard to find an updated menu from Lorenzos as they utilize Facebook for advertising. I've been craving their cheese fries for weeks so back to Lorenzos it was. I ordered a drunk grandma, a family special and of course, cheese fries. Everything was phenomenally good, except I'm not sure what pizza we ended up getting as it wasn't a dunken grandma. It was a Sicilian with marinara and roasted garlic cloves. It was pretty off-putting but I can imagine if you like garlic like that it would be good. I really miss lorenzos and wish they would utilize an online platform. I understand this is probably a cost they don't want to absorb. Maybe just an easier way to access an updated menu would be an option, even through wix or something. I do want to also add that Lorenzos supports our local community in many ways, including supporting our youth sports and our local fire department. That's huge when you're looking to support a business with a large weekly order. I'll be back for more cheese fries and that vintage home town atmosphere

We used Lorenzo’s for catering for my sister in laws surprise party. The food was amazing and so delicious. The best tortellini and vodka sauce, eggplant rolotini, stuffed shells, sausage and peppers, buttered noodles and sauce, chicken franchisee, chicken parmigiana . We also ordered a antipasto salad and regular salad. Lori and Dave made the party stress free by allowing us to order rolls and butter directly from them as well. We were so impressed with the service they provided with the delivery and set up and even went above and beyond to package all the leftovers in containers they provided for us to take home. If you are thinking about having a party they definitely were amazing to our family. Thank you all! Thank you Dave, Colleen and Vermanda for your service and support in making this event a hit.

We decided to hit up Lorenzo’s after witnessing the absolute Yelp meltdown happening down the street at Brothers. Like… we came for dinner, and ended up deep in a saga of overcooked calamari, customer service stand-offs, and more plot twists than a group chat gone wrong. But Lorenzo’s? Lorenzo’s is peace. Personal pies that were genuinely delicious, crisp crust, rich sauce, melty cheese, and that perfect balance that lets you know someone back there actually cares about what they’re serving. It was so good, we barely looked up from our food while reading those dramatic reviews like court transcripts. The staff is super friendly, too! The kind of place where they remember your order, treat you like a regular even if it’s your first time, and make you feel like part of the family. Honestly, if you’re looking for a spot to celebrate… oh, I don’t know… your husband’s birthday, this is the place. No stress, no drama, just good food and good people. If you want great pizza and a quiet life, come here. If you want chaos, well… you know where to look. Just grab a slice from Lorenzo’s first. You’ll need the emotional support.

We ordered Vegetarian Options. Must say the food was really good. Also the staff was good. If in Sussex and want to eat Italian Food, then recommended!